On Deadbeat Dads

The best Christmas gift is parental responsibility
There’s a holiday in late December that I call Deadbeat Dad Week. It falls a week after Christmas, because that’s when gifts from absentee fathers show up in the mail. Deadbeat Dads send their parcels on December 24. They never have any idea what their kids want for Christmas. They just buy the most nifty, outrageous thing they come across.

When I was eight, in Montreal during the 1980s, my friend Stuart was sent a Great Dane puppy and needed a paper route to afford the dog food. Marie received a strobe light for the ceiling of her bedroom. Ted opened an enormous box and discovered a foot-wide tennis ball. Jean-Phillippe got the best gift: a megaphone. He stood outside repeating, “Step away from your vehicle,” to people getting into their cars.

Deadbeat Dad typically wears sunglasses and leather jackets. He has long hair, even though he’s balding on top. He rides a skateboard at age thirty-five. He’s fit, and is often spotted in the playground doing chin-ups on the monkey bars. When children are with Deadbeat Dad, they always feel in the flush of a new relationship. Everything Deadbeat Dad says is a riot. He does the most exciting things. He wrestles snakes! He eats shark! He runs into Ozzy Osbourne in bars!

The Parent TrapA public shaming for negligent dads and momsIllustration by Patrick KylePatrick KyleMany frustrated parents would like to collar and chip their elusive baby daddies/mamas, but the Ontario Ministry of Community and Social Services has the next best solution. In 2007, the ministry’s Family Responsibility Office started goodparentspay.com, a registry of dads (and, as of press time, one mom) who have defaulted on their support payments. Each offender’s name and picture is posted, along with known aliases and other distinguishing marks (e.g., Pegasus, Superman, and dragon tattoos). The site is intended to invite tips about the parents’ whereabouts, and, like sex offender registries, it serves to stigmatize the deadbeats who fail to come through for their kids. — Naomi Skwarna
Deadbeat Dad never has a steady paycheque. His excuses for this are epic, and should be published in pocket-sized form, just like those books of quotations from Oscar Wilde. Deadbeat Dad always claims that money is coming. He says he plans to open a massage parlour in the garage. He’s awaiting a court settlement from being bitten by a German shepherd in Detroit. He bought a painting at a yard sale that he’s sure is worth a bundle.

Deadbeat Dad thinks he has a calling. He has shoeboxes filled with demo tapes he recorded in his bathroom, where “the acoustics are awesome.” He has notebooks filled with ballpoint pen drawings of horses. He writes poetry on the back of paper placemats.

Deadbeat Dad likes to remind his children that they exist because of his marvellous genes. Thanks to them, his kids are good in sports, ace spelling bees, and land their first jobs at Dunkin’ Donuts. Deadbeat Dad acts as if his genes are the magic beans his children’s mother traded her future for.

Deadbeat Dad is always a little depressed. After all, he has time on his hands to wallow in self-pity. He’d never have time for existential dilemmas if he were actually raising his kids.

Deadbeat Dad gets arrested for possessing unlicensed firearms or disturbing the peace. He has issues with drugs and alcohol. He is a good time, with his video arcades, roller coasters, and Whack-a-Moles, but he is a stranger to his children. He doesn’t know their favourite books. He doesn’t know the name of the bully who teased his son in grade four. He doesn’t take his daughter out for dinner after she stars in her school play. He disappears for long stretches, during which children grow up.

Once his children are grown, Deadbeat Dad might come back to make amends. He wants to be close to his kids, like other parents. To this end, he uses “the apology.” Apologies are like flowers that bloom on the side of a cactus. They’re startling and lovely. Sadly, though, they are not time machines, and Deadbeat Dad cannot use them to travel back and show up at your eighth birthday party.

My daughter went to meet her biological father last year, just after Christmas. He said he wanted to give her presents to her in person. She hadn’t seen him since she was five. Back then, he’d disappear on week-long benders. He’d show up high as a kite to take her to the park. He’d entertain her with handstands and juggling and then fall asleep on a bench.

He stole my clothes and school books. He stole my television, guitar, and radio. I’d pass the pawnshop and see half my apartment for sale in the window. He never paid a penny of child support, and after years of begging and taking him to court I gave up. Ten years went by, and my daughter and I almost forgot he existed. He never came up in conversation. We were reminded of him only when the presents arrived at Christmas and on her birthday. They were good gifts: iPods, cameras, and other things I couldn’t afford.

My daughter wanted to meet him, and I couldn’t dissuade her. She brought her dog along, full of expectations. She was taken aback from the get-go. His front tooth was broken in half. He had a new girlfriend with him, who sat silently observing them. Circling his arm was a tattoo of a squid, which he claimed was his favourite animal. He was working as a bicycle courier and was still broke.

I asked her if she found that her dad looked like her.

“My God, yes. It was shocking! All the missing features!”

“Will you see him again?”

“No,” she said. “He made me feel weird. I almost wish I’d never met him. Why didn’t you stop me?”

One of the burdens of single motherhood is letting children figure out the truth about Deadbeat Dads on their own. Maybe it’s for the best that my daughter writes her father off. Deadbeat Dads can never give you anything but shiny baubles and disappearing acts. It never pays to love them. One thing that’s true about all Deadbeat Dads is that they’ll break your heart.

31 comment(s)

AnonymousNovember 14, 2010 18:20 EST

This is satire, right? No mom would ever refuse to let Dad communicate with his children so it must be dad's fault.

HilaryNovember 15, 2010 16:38 EST

I have spent 15 years dealing with a Deadbeat Dad so similar to the one described by Heather O'Neill. The only difference is we never had to be reminded of him twice per year as birthday and Chrsitmas gifts never came, otherwise the resemblance is uncanny.

AnonymousNovember 16, 2010 00:59 EST

Touching piece for anyone who's been there. Thank you.

AnonymousNovember 16, 2010 14:57 EST

I am dad myself. Altough I pay consistently on support payments, I feel like a deadbeat dad. I cannot afford to live on my own for them to be able to comfortably be with me. I cannot afford to take them on trips anywhere. I just live pay to pay and I live and work for them. I feel it's hardly fair to brush with the same stroke when it comes to dad's who's children live with their mother's.

I would love to be able to have them in my life and to go to different places and do all kinds of things with them, but I can't afford to.

Not even the Canadian government appreciates father's who support their children financially. Not even the recognition that they live in poverty to pay for the children. Since 1996 we cannot even get a tax break from paying support.

John FairweatherNovember 16, 2010 14:57 EST

When are we going to stop talking about Deadbeat Dads and start talking about Deadbeat Parents. I know of a number of Deadbeat Moms, and the latest statistics in the U.S. show more mothers refusing to make child support payments than fathers.

I also notice that many Deadbeat Dads were Deadbeat Partners first, but that doesn't seem to stop women from having babies with these losers. If a man cheats on you, disrespects you, steal from you and can't, or won't, keep a decent job, then maybe you should think twice before you have a baby with him. Find a decent man and you might find a decent dad at the same time.

Single mumNovember 17, 2010 09:16 EST

Dear Anonymous November 16, 2010 14:57 EST
I just want to say that it does not cost a dime to get a pen and paper to write a note to your kids to say " i love you" or a quick trip to the library or perhaps even a short walk around the block to ask "how are you doing in school?" or "what's new?, I miss you!" These examples of small acts of love are priceless to a child. Regardless of the messy, confusing, and always heartbreaking break-up of mum's and dad's (because we're so God dang mad at each other we lose sight of what is best for our little ones), really, they just want to know that both of us love them unconditionally. Most times, money is not even an issue for them. But you would think that your child(ren) need the most basic things in life...a home, electricity, running water, clothing, food, you know.. child support! Your comments sounds like you feel pity on yourself, this is not about you is it?...wait until your old and grey and have no one to take care of you. Then we would really blame the government because it didn't give you a tax break!

AnonymousNovember 17, 2010 12:00 EST

Dear SINGLE MUM,

Your response completely misses the point I was trying to make, but also provides in-sight into the point I was trying to make. It’s that kind of attitude that really doesn’t help the plight of father’s who continually pay support. I was not complaining about having to support my children.
I think it’s about time shed some light on us who struggle in life while maintaining our support to our children.
By the way, I would absolutely do all the things you mentioned that do not cost money, but my children live in another city in another Province. I cannot afford to go see them or buy them airline tickets to come and visit me.
Thanks, but no thanks. I wasn’t looking for more of that kind of drivel.

AnonymousNovember 21, 2010 22:19 EST

The author writes "Deadbeat Dad is always a little depressed. After all, he has time on his hands to wallow in self-pity. He’d never have time for existential dilemmas if he were actually raising his kids."

This article sounds like it was written by some one who is a little depressed, more than a little angry, full of self-pity, and smack in the middle of an existential dilemmas. By their own estimation they shouldn't have time to raise kids in this condition.

Hilary November 22, 2010 14:53 EST

This is in response to the last "Anonymous" post. It seems to me as though the author has struck a chord with this individual. Perhaps the author is a little depressed having to have raised a child single handedly while putting up with the come and go antics of Deadbeat dad. Years of struggling to create a positive life for ones child while they constantly ask why their dad doesn't want to see them does take a toll. However, her statement, "ten years went by, and my daughter and I almost forgot he existed." doesn't exactly leave me with the impression she was "more than a little angry". It leaves me with the impression that she and her daughter had become content with how things were prior to being ambushed with another resurgence of Deadbeat dad. One of the most difficult things for parents "smack in the middle" of Deadbeat drama is dealing with the aftermath of the vanishing act. By this time Deadbeat dad is long gone and all the emotions his last resurgence have caused still must be dealt with. Maybe this is where the "full of self pity" part comes into play. Many times I have felt sorry for myself that I am the one dealing with my daughter sobbing in my bed at 2 am asking what she did to make him leave again knowing no answer will ever cure that hurt and that I have to be up for work in 4 hours.

In fairness to others I must point out that not all Deadbeats are dads. There are many dads struggling to raise children on their own while dealing with Deadbeat mom. The point is that at least one parent realizes the role of parent is not an optional one.

AnonymousNovember 24, 2010 21:59 EST

WOW! These comments are EXTREMLY helpful! The good and the bad! I have 2 children ages 14 and 4. My 14 year old has a GREAT Father! He is involved and has been from the very start. A post stated "Deadbeat Dads were Deadbeat Partners first!" That statement is SO TRUE! Yes, the signs were there to run, but I did not, STUPID ME! My 4 year old's Dad is the epitomy of a Deadbeat Dad. The description above is DEAD ON! Although I am relieved that I was not crazy (as he has stated each time we may run into him) and am not the only single Mother dealing with this issue, it also terribly pains me that the issue of Deadbeat Parents is so widespread. I dont feel good about it, but knowing what I know now, I cannot blame anyone else but myself. I put myself through this (with a little bit of his help, if u know what I mean) all 9 months of my pregnancy without even a call, then the once a year appearances. When we do see him, he gets angry because he expects a marching band celebration when our Son sees him. Then he uses that interaction as a reason why another 2 years go by implying that WE (my son and I) were mean to him and didnt appreciate seeing him. At the end of he day, like the other posts, I am the one who is answering my sons questions about his Daddy and trying to pacify him and or turn his attention to something else. ITS VERY PAINFUL, from childbirth to Single Motherhood. It has its perks but in the end my son loses. I can only HOPE that he is a better Father to his children.

anonymousNovember 26, 2010 15:30 EST

wow some of the comments totally explain my x husband. But he was charged with harrassement, breached thru our 9 year old son sending messages and then calls him a liar to his face and now is going to make him testify against his dad, but he loves him! He is over 25 thousand in arrears for child support and yet lives the high life, competes in bodybuilding and buy the children, and yet says he has no money, coming from a trades man who can work as much as he wants. \Went without talking or being with his children for 8 months and not once made arrangements but blames me.Sad to say but he is the definition of a dead beat father, who denies the one child oh and then has a 13 year old he doesnt support either, but this is a man that says he acts in the best interest of his children, Bad mouthing the mother of the children when i have to support the visits that i have to force my children to go to.
Meanwhile i am a single mother who barely makes it, has exhausted all resources for help because there is a court order stating i cannot leave to go home with family because supposidly he wants to be a father, I wonder if he even knows what that means? But i guess i am to blame because i stayed with him for so long through the mental and physical abuse right? I am the one who picks up the pieces of the hurt of the children from him, the one who answers all the questions. But he is allowed to see the children even though he doesnt support them or act in a loving way or act or talk or do anything in their best interest when in fact all he is doing is destroyiing my children slowly!
I know this man will never wake up and be a decent father to these children, I just hope someone when they absolutely hate him and realize everything he did to them and their mother that maybe someday they might possibly forgive him for being such a dead bead loser!

ScottDecember 01, 2010 08:45 EST

What is the purpose of this article? Not all divorced fathers are deadbeat fathers. If you lose your job you instantly become a deadbeat father? Perhaps the writer could examine not only deadbeat fathers but society as a whole and what leads to the broken family. When job security was common we had fewer problems, when we had less media-driven upbringing and role modeling. What is a family? Is it the Walton's? We need more realistic and positive media with values. Contrary to how the article portrays men in general, most fathers love their children. I am sorry for the writer's sad experience.

AnonymousDecember 02, 2010 16:57 EST

Me

There are many sad stories with deadbeat father\\\'s/parents. Unfortunately, most are dads in Canada.

Sometimes circumstances happen and the paying parent looses their job, etc., making payments difficult to meet.
Does that justify not paying?Not at all. These children did not ask to be here. Even in the animal kingdom, the parents give everything and risk their lives for the children\\\'s survival.
And yes usually, it\\\'s the \\\"protective mother\\\" the babies spend most of their time with but father\\\'s teach survival skills and safety. Knowledge and communication at an intellectual level is what distinguishes us from the animal kingdom. We are supposed to be better than \\\"wild animals\\\"

If you look around you and you really want to work, there is work. Immigrants seem to be doing quite well with all their language barriers and challenges to find work. This country was built on hard work and sacrifice of challenged immigrants. Most came here because this is a land of opportunity. What do these people see that these deadbeats don\\\'t see?

Sacrifice; That\\\'s what you do for your children so they can be safe, give them hope for opportunity, care for them, live, teach our children morals and set positive goals for themselves.

The worst, and sadly there are so many more and unfortunate souls that waddle in their self-pity, many of these deadbeat father\\\'s/parents can very much afford to provide a good life for their children but to spite their ex-spouse, they hide behind numbered companies and untraceable income so they can make life difficult for the custodial parent. What they don\\\'t realize that it is a domino effect and the children ultimately suffer.

Even when they spoil the children during their visitations the children are suffering. One can say they try to \\\"buy\\\" their children\\\'s love and affection. Who\\\'s the fool and what are we teaching the next generation?These are the worst type of people. Theses individual think they are \\\"god\\\" and they think they have the rights to act in this manner and \\\"punish\\\".

Tax breaks...If you don\\\'t have a job and you don\\\'t make any money you don\\\'t need a tax break. When you need a tax break you are making money.

This article may have stimulated related or distantly related topics to deadbeat dads. I can understand that sensitivity to this topic is global.
I sincerely sympathize with the author and hope that he/she has found some healing in writing. Hopefully life has blessed him/her with other charms.
Our life\\\'s experiences are what make us \\\"better\\\" and \\\"stronger\\\".
God bless you and have a Merry Christmas with all the positive special people in your life.

Your story has been positive in making us all aware,,look how many comments you have. That in its self is great.

AnonymousDecember 16, 2010 14:54 EST

This is an essay? Maybe a rant, but definitely not an essay.

An essay would have some self-awareness and insight, and might recognize, for instance, that at one point the "Deadbeat Dad" was somebody the author had decided to have sex with, maybe even be in a relationship with.

How do you explain that choice to your daughter? Now that would be an interesting article.

Otherwise, "deadbeat dads", just like its inverse, "power moms", is simply a tired, lazy cliche.

AnonymousDecember 17, 2010 14:33 EST

"Deadbead Dad" are pretty much the same, exept my kids never got birthday or christmas gifts. He has been hounded by family maintenance but still manages to avoid them by working under the table because they could not find any source of income. Years pass and the children grow. My son has not seen his father since my son was 3 months old. My x was not only abuses to me but to the children and lost visitation and spent time in jail. He claimed it was the children's fault he hurt them. Some dead beats are worse then others, but they are only concerned with one person themselves.

AnonymousDecember 17, 2010 14:34 EST

Thank you anonymous December 16!! I feel the same way. These women are stupid because they obviously have bad taste in mates. They chose to have sex and get pregnant and then have a child they knew they could not afford. They chose to depend on a man. Either they want equal rights or they don't... if they do they need to start ensuring their future via education and jobs and not getting knocked up and 12 or while uneducated or unemployed. If you can't afford the kid alone on your own don't have the kid to begin with. Children are not and should not be used as meal tickets... even though apparently a lot of people think oh I know I'll have a kid and he'll have to pay me and then when he doesn't they want to cry and complain. It was their own bad judgment that got them into this situation. BTW, it takes TWO people to have sex... so last time I check besides the judgment call, the woman is equally responsible. Why do they ever depend on men knowing their is a good chance they will leave them in the dust? Are they really that desperate for love?

AnonymousJanuary 03, 2011 15:38 EST

My Ode to Deadbeat Dads

I would like to say that although I can't believe I made it, my kids are smart, professional and sucessful, I did it myself. However, it is hard, so hard to always be the better person. To stand back and allow him to sweep my daughters off their feet like superman." He's so buff!" {My daughter told me proudly yesterday" Did I say, "oh that's because he spent hours everyday lifting weights and looking at himself in the mirror while I did all all the work. No I just said that's great that he is such good shape. Oh, do they really know the truth, my intelligent daughters, do they really believe he couldn't be responsible or is it that it just doesn't matter. is it more important to have a fantasy about this deadbeat dad then really face the facts. Not only was he unavailabe - he did not answer their letters, phone calls and my plees. It is again my role to be supportive, patient and quiet. No reminders of the years i was alone to drive to the hospital and stay up all night with chicken pox and ear aches and tonsilitis. No reminders of the defiant teenage years, when smoking and drug experiementing and climbing out of windows, and boys trying to have sex with my virgin daughters and me being there to protect them through that, and then there was the time when my daughter was she was bullied and I put her in a different school, found the right program for her..... Then they were agaisnt all my values, higher education, , anti this antil that. Oh then when that all changed, and they were going to go on to Higher education , then when they realized they were going to university and Mom was right and then how to pay the bills.....o h yes, how convenient to show up and then take out your beautiful accomplished daughters and revel in the results of my good parenting and sacrafices. Do these guys really believe their children's success has anything to do with them? "Just this week the guy shows up after all these years,( oh yes, it is such a coincidence it is Christmas.) Here he is a like a long awaited hero and poof, he gets the benefit of all my life's devotion and work. he gets to show off his lovely daughters and enjoy them . It is far from fair........ and then there is the eternal question, how long will this new found fatherhood last this time?

AnonymousJanuary 11, 2011 11:43 EST

A True Dead Beat Dad.

I have been fighting my daughters deadbeat dad for support since we divorced in 1988. He would show up sometimes for visitation and then disappear for months on end. Always to be seen at the Bingo hall or Casino`s but never paid support. As my daughter grew up she always idiolized her father and said ``he would never disappoint me``. Went to court finally 3 years ago and cut the arrears in half from $15,000+ to $7500 and he was to pay $300. per month. My daughter got married 2 years ago and he told her he would pay half for her wedding day. Well at least he paid $200.00 towards the flowers, but the bride and groom had to pay for his Tux rental of $200 so that became a total wash, and no real wedding present from him. To this day he still owes over $5800 in support and is now a grandfather who never see`s his grandchild, avoids calls from his daughter because he thinks she is going to always ask for money, and gives the excuse that he cannot see her as he has no car, no drivers license(as that was taken away over 5 years ago and blames me). A true deadbeat dad but his daughter is starting to learn what he is truly like. He missed out on her life and he is missing out on his granddaughters life and he always blames everyone else and still refuses to take on responsiblilty.

AnonymousJanuary 30, 2011 20:43 EST

I'm a deadbeat dad...left my family after I went bankrupt supporting them, including my abusive spouse who never worked, because, in her words, supporting her and the children is the man's responsibility. Her family hired her lawyers, and, with the full support of a sympathetic legal system, generous payments were ordered. I lost the car and the apartment I used for visitations, and the children have been told I am worthless, untrustworthy, and don't care about them.

I work hard at the same salaried job I had when I was married, but after taxes and garnished wages, I live well below the poverty line. My 50% wage garnishee (off the gross) does not cover my support obligation. Meanwhile the children are better off financially now than they ever were.

In hindsight, I never should have married the spoiled brat, who is once again fully supported by her parents, with contributions from me and the government. But I did, and we had children. I try to keep in touch with them, but they reject communication, with the full support of their mother, who tells them they are better off without me in their lives. Meanwhile, I keep paying everything I can, and fall further into arrears.

SorryFebruary 23, 2011 17:24 EST

I am sorry for us all. Sorry for the failed relationships and the resulting bitterness, sorry for the children who grow up without the love and support of both parents, sorry for dads (or moms) who pay half their wages and don\\\'t see their children as much as they would like, sorry for moms (or dads) who raise children alone and must pick up the pieces after they are abandoned. What are the lessons to be learned? What is the higher truth in all this hurt?

WowzersMarch 20, 2011 21:06 EST

This article is insanely dead on! My heart goes out to all the moms and children who have had the pleasure of dealing with this type. It's really enough to make anyone crazy and the sad part is that it's a life sentence. Oh yes, and my heart actually somewhat goes out to these deadbeats who will eventually grow up and realize that you don't get a second chance to watch your children grow up.

Boo Hoo to the dads who can't afford to live. Are you kidding me? The small portion that comes off of your cheques to pay child support is nothing compared to the cost of actually raising kids. I only wish that 35% of my cheques went towards my kids rather than the 100% that I currently pay. And to the man who went bankrupt because of his wife and kids..c'mon now can you even hear what you are saying? Cry me a river.

At any rate, I had to comment on how accurately the deadbeat type can be described. Self pity seems to be the most common thread. And for the record I don't have any self pity. I blame myself 100% for choosing the wrong person to be the father of my children. Until my kids turn 18 and are off on their own, it is my responsibility to make sure they never suffer from my mistakes again.

DeadbeatDecember 19, 2011 10:55 EST

What everyone forgets is the pain of being a non-residential parent. The pain of losing your family. Losing your kids. Having to fight to prove that you're still a good parent. When your ex's significant other can see your kids every day of the week, but you only get every other weekend. Being labeled a "deadbeat" by unscrupulous attorneys for bitter ex-spouses. Having to pay your ex's attorneys fees so they can continue to punish you in court. Then there's the child support and all the financial pain one must face with that. No wonder so many non-residential parents check out, frustrated, lonely and depressed. Calling someone a "deadbeat" can be a self-fulfilling prophesy. Some turn to alcohol/drugs/exercise/bad relationships/workaholism, etc. — anything to dull the pain. I wonder if this is what happened to the deadbeat dad of the original author's essay? God knows it happened to me.

The legal system that purports to promote "the best interests of the child" in fact creates many situations that destroy parents lives and ultimately hurts the children. The system has become a weapon one bitter parent can use against the other. How often have you heard this scenario: one parent sneaks away with the kids when the other is at work and justifies it by alleging abuse. Later rather than sooner the allegations are withdrawn or proven unfounded, but the damage is done. Residency has been established and there is nothing the non-residential parent can do about it. He/she has to transition back to some semblance of a regular visitation schedule to see his/her kids. The system rewards this behavior pattern by not punishing those making false allegations. This scenario happens all the time and the courts are full of cases just like it. I wonder what percentage of abuse allegations really turn out to be true? The real beneficiaries of this system are the leagues of lawyers, evaluators, psychologists, bar associations, court officials, and yes, judges — that have overflowing caseloads and a steady stream of income.

beachlassJanuary 02, 2012 22:00 EST

As I go to pick up a disappointed kid who is being shipped home a week early because his dad can't be bothered to keep him over New Year's I needed to reread this, and remind myself that we're not alone.

Thank you.

AnonymousJanuary 29, 2012 22:58 EST

The unrelenting negativity towards the father in this article is completely unbalanced. Reducing your own child's father to nothing more than the single phrase "deadbeat dad"? Really? The mother couldn't be more uncharitable, or self centered. Her child is obviously drowning in the message that her father doesn't love her and that she comes from a father who is no good. I can't think of a more unhealthy message for a child's self esteem.

It also creates a selfish child. If we would want our children to behave charitably towards people on the street who have met with misfortune or who have shortcomings, then how could we ever justify encouraging our children to cut off their own family members because of small shortcomings? Even worse their own parents! Children grow by being given responsibility. For a child to say "I don't think I'll talk to my father again" ignores their responsibility to love and be respectful to their own family. Accommodating our family is how we learn maintain relationships. The mother is setting her daughter up to repeat the cycle of looking for a man without flaws who will take care of all her needs, fix all her problems, and need nothing in return (a good thing if the daughter wasn't taught any responsibility in the home and can't give anything to a man in return). The search for that superman inevitably ends in finding someone who gives them nothing but empty promises. A fair bargain. Nothing for nothing.

It is a woman's nature to use children to get money from men. It is a man's nature to use money to get children from women. This will never change. All that can change is taking a moment to step into the other parents shoes for a moment, and recognize that love for children takes different forms for men and women, but different does not mean less important or valid and that it is important for the child to see the positive.

Yes some things will never change. Men don't vote to support reform and equal parenting because men are only effective in lobbying for the things they really want like money and power and other things they need to get women. Women are far more effective at lobbying for what they really want which is power over men. Most men don't have a clue about the bias towards mothers in the family courts until they get there and discover father's have no rights. When the situation befalls them it's too late. Facing the full might of the government they may refuse to be controlled and abused, so they withhold funds because they feel they have been denied the right to have their own children in their lives.

Almost all parents who deny access are mothers, and almost all parents who deny support are fathers. There's a simple solution to this. More equal parenting. Better for both women and men.

Finally, it is typical that yet another of this type of article pandering to the hoards of "holier than thou" feminists would find its way here. What would be far more interesting is publishing AT LEAST ONE essay from an anti-feminist point of view.

the child, grown-upFebruary 10, 2012 09:08 EST

Dear Heather,
Thanks for sharing. Maybe not everyone can relate to every detail of your story, but I understand it all too well. I was the child in your story that was ignored and emotionally toyed with for years... Who was promised presents of cars, clothes, and trips that never materialized.

One Christmas as I went to visit his new mansion home and my stepbrother was adored with video game systems, games, a laptop and more... he gave me a sweater that couldn't have cost him more than five dollars.

My deadbeat dad placed the responsibility of communication on me when I was a teenager.. and by placed I mean yelled at me in public. Apparently it was my fault we didn't see each other more. He never could take responsibility for his short-comings.

I am 26 years old now. We hadn't spoken in years. I heard through the grape vine that he was going through his second divorce. Two weeks ago was my birthday, and there was a knock at the door. My mother answered. He yelled at her. "Your father's here," she said with a chilled voice. (She was never happy we stopped speaking, but she learned not to push me on the matter over the years.)
I took a deep breath, shook my head, and walked towards the door. He stood there wearing his favourite items, sunglasses and a leather jacket. He started blaming me for us not talking. He demanded I pay him respect. I remained mostly silent. His voice lowered, then he said I could call him if I needed anything.

I told him that as I child I needed him and he was not there. I told him that I'm an adult now. I told him that I don't need anything from him. I asked him, what could he now possibly offer? I told him, I was unwilling to speak with him, unless he admitted to all that he had done, apologize, and promise some sort of change. That I would only speak with him if he took responsibility for all the days and moments I when I needed him and he wasn't there. He told me that I should apologize to him. I thought to myself, I didn't come knocking at his door. He demanded I call him on February 1st (it's February 10th). He said he'd be finished some business and that he was free to talk to (not with) me then (his business was finishing up with his second divorce). Of course he wants my attention when it's convenient for him, and to call him when it suits his schedule and he's alone again. I didn't call.

It hurts being the daughter of a deadbeat dad, who doesn't speak his name to her friends and hopes that no one asks. It hurts even more knowing that he has a multitude of money, and refused to help out with my sister and I to spite my mother. It hurts remembering my mother going to food banks and while he went on lavish vacations. I hurts when he would put me on display and take credit for my development, when he played no positive or progressive role

A close friend referred to my father as a 'deadbeat dad'. I was shocked when she did. It certainly wasn't her place to speak of him like that. But she was right. I never used the term before, but it does describes him... down to the not paying child support when I was younger and the province revoking his driver's licence... and him blaming my mother rather than himself.

For those who have commented, debate all you'd like about your distaste for the expression, 'deadbeat'. But for myself, the word fits.

Anyway, I just wanted to say, thanks for sharing your story.

PrometheusFebruary 10, 2012 11:47 EST

The unrelenting negativity towards the father in this article is completely unbalanced and formulaic. The father is a caricature, reduced to the single phrase "deadbeat dad". Really?

The piece intended to evoke empathy but there were too many shortcomings in the mother's position for the writing to be of any depth. She couldn't have been more uncharitable or self centered. Her child was obviously drowning in the message that her father didn't love her and that she came from a father who was no good. I can't think of a more unhealthy message for a child's self esteem.

On a personal note I believe this also creates a selfish child. If we would want our children to behave charitably towards people on the street who are down on their luck, who might look funny or smell weird, or who are just plain crazy, then how could we ever justify encouraging our children to cut off their own family members because of small shortcomings? Even worse their own parents! Children grow by being given responsibility. For a child to say "I don't think I'll talk to my father again" ignores their responsibility to love and be respectful to their own family. Accommodating our imperfect family is how we learn to maintain relationships. The mother in this essay is setting her daughter up to repeat the cycle of looking for a man without flaws who will take care of all her needs, fix all her problems, and need nothing in return (a good thing if the daughter wasn't taught any responsibility in the home and can't give anything to a man in return). The search for that superman inevitably ends in finding someone who gives them nothing but empty promises, exactly like the man the father was portrayed to do. A fair bargain. Nothing for nothing.

When will there be some writing that honestly explores some of the obvious and perhaps uncomfortable truths in this equation? It's a woman's nature to use children to get money from men. It is a man's nature to use money to get women so they can produce children. Failing to acknowledge these fundamental differences between men and women fuels the war between the sexes, and enables the kind of misandry spewing forth from the writer's essay.

This political environment doesn't promote honest introspection and debate. Men don't vote to support reform and equal parenting because men lobby for the things they really want like money and power and other things they need to get women. Women are far more effective at lobbying for what they really want which is power over men. The status quo in the family courts is not about justice, but about the organization and influence of the feminist movement. Most men don't have a clue about the bias towards mothers in the family courts until they get there and discover father's have no rights. By then it's too late. Facing the full might of the government they may refuse to be controlled and abused, so they withhold funds because they feel they have been denied the right to have their own children in their lives. Women in turn deny their children access to their fathers as leverage. It's a war in which everyone loses.

Almost all parents who deny access are mothers, and almost all parents who deny support are fathers. There's a simple solution to this. More equal parenting. Better for both women and men.

On another note, it's typical that yet another of this type of article pandering to the hoards of lifelong career "feminist victims" would find its way to a CanLit "zine". Will this stop the trend of young male's refusing to read fiction? Publish AT LEAST ONE essay from an anti-misandry point of view. Save us readers from death due to the overwhelming dullness of more of the same.

SherrisMarch 13, 2012 10:36 EST

My son has a deadbeat dad.... and yet he figures the sun rises and sets on him.

My son is now 19 and in university - his dad and I have been separated since my son was 8 months old.... Dad decided he didn\'t want a family...

His dad has always paid 70% less than the guidelines, has never assisted with child support or with his athletics.... never more than the bare minimum... Why? Because I believed him when he said \"I\'m broke\". I asked year after year for a copy of his tax returns, he\'d write back saying he\'s only making 34,000 a year and supporting a wife and 3 children - he didn\'t have any more for his first son. OK.... I bit....

My son started University and I sent him another letter laying out the school costs and asked for some assistance... He replied with having me served with court documents to cancel his child support.

So, we both played by the rules ~ he submitted his incomes, I submitted mine, we both submitted our expenses... yada, yada, yada.... turns out when he was claiming \"poverty and only making $34,000 a year\", he was actually making $120,000 plus....

The judge didn\'t see much humour in it and ordered an increased support amount as well as extra ordinary expenses for school costs.... I didn\'t ask for any back support - just help with school.

Now dear old dad is claiming poverty to my son and playing him against me and making me the bad guy.... REALLY?!

How does one keep trudging along knowing that the deadbeat dad is making 3 times what you make in a year... has a $350,00 in equity in his home.... has a wife that chooses not to work (kids 13, 11, 7).... how do you make your son see the light? Dear old dad still manages to put away money into his other 3 boy\'s RESP\'s and money into his RRSP\'s.....

Not all mom\'s collecting child support are money grabbing cows.... sometimes, mom\'s are just looking for some help....

Just saying.....

DEB FLOYDSApril 05, 2012 12:27 EST

I am so tired of women calling the father of their childred \\\\\\\" deadbeat dads\\\\\\\". Women theses days are getting together and discussing how they can get rid of their husbands and take them to the cleaners. These women are so into themselves that they no longer have family values and no longer care about nothing but themselves. I have and EX daughter in law who decided she wanted to be single, but wanted my son to support her. My son cares for his children very much, His son is living with him but his \\\\\\\"mother\\\\\\\" still wants support payment for him. She buys expnsive shoes, clothing, manis, pedis, tanning,, etc. for herself, but has not once contributed to her son. But she still wants payment for child support even though she does not have him living with her. She is all about money and nothing else. It is time these women were stopped!!!!

BeckyApril 06, 2012 20:38 EST

I'm so shocked at how many posters blame the mother in this article. Give your heads a shake. Men don't need women to baby them and to force them to grow up and be responsible.

My son's father is a deadbeat. He lost his drivers licence in February because he couldn't seem to pay support. In the meantime, he continued to sport the newest Iphone, went on vacations and lived a comfortable lifestyle. Heck, even if he had called and acknowledged Christmas, birthdays, sent email or tried to make some contact, he wouldn't be deemed a deadbeat.

He is not a bad guy. He's just a young 38. His mom still does everything for him and bails him out of bankruptcy. He cannot keep a job and I know he did have a gambling addiction a few years ago when we last spoke.

Anyway, I am now remarried. My husband raises our son as his own. The sad twist is while the deadbeat is super fertile, my sweet husband is infertile. He would do anything to have a child and it's incredibly difficult to see how unfair life can be.

In the meantime, we work hard to keep our son happy and secure. He used to ask about his father and about the things his father had promised him, but he now, thankfully has Dave to identify with. Dave and I struggle with what to tell him if he does ask about him or if he does call again. We live everyday worrying that the bio dad will make contact, only to disappear again while we pick up the pieces.

Bitter? Yes, sometimes. But I just want the best for my little boy. He deserves to have security and comfort and I do not want a deadbeat waltzing in and out of his life just to ease his own conscience. If he were to come in and stay, that's one thing, but way too confusing for a young boy to hear from him once a year.

Thank for you this article. I was looking for advice about how to speak to my son about this if it ever came up. In the meantime, I feel comforted knowing that we are not alone.

BeckyApril 07, 2012 18:01 EST

To those who get hyper focused on what the mother uses her own money for, you need to look at the big picture.

Most of the non-custodial parents do not have to pay for the day to day things. My ex only has to pay 1/3 of everything, but rarely pays. That money goes towards the care of the child and if the child is well cared for, then it's none of your business what she does with her own money.

Also, the article is about deadbeat fathers. If you feel like your friend/son/brother is being mistreated, then maybe this article isn't aimed at them? If they are responsible parents, have regular contact with their children and are paying support, they are not deadbeats. It's that easy.

I bet my ex mother-in-law doesn't know what her son does or doesn't do. He was never one to tell her why his lost his latest job, why he had his truck taken from a repo man or why his cell phone number always changed. So, deep down, I know she knows her son, but I don't think she is aware of the full story.

AnonymousApril 13, 2012 15:59 EST

All this is true depending on the perspective. Maybe I should have ran from their dad instead of marrying him, but I wouldn\'t have these wonderful kids or the experiences that provided me with knowledge to help other struggling familes. And yeah I\'m in a position to do that and love my career. I work full time, bring work home, and care for my kiddos w/o help. Yes he pays support b/c he thinks he\'ll go straight to jail if he doesn\'t. So he is now keeping a job so they can garnish him. But the deadbeat comes into play with visits. He only sees them on average once every 3 weeks b/c he allows the new girlfriend/baby momma to call the shots. So the visits aren\'t consistent. Maybe once a week for several weeks then he\'ll go a month till the next one. Thats what sucks...they don\'t know when they can count on him. When my son was recently admitted to the hospital the dad doesn\'t show up, doesn\'t ask to speak to my son, doesn\'t bother to ask where my daughter would be staying, and still hasn\'t asked what the diagnosis was. He\'s great when he has them, but no different than a good babysitter. The lack of visits also sucks cuz it means a lack of a break on my end. Thats not to be selfish...but sometimes I need to recharge so I can be a good mom. Sometimes I wish he would decide either be a real dad or no dad...this maybe I\'ll play dad if the mood is right simply isn\'t working. I try to give credit where credit is due, but I\'m just not feeling sympathetic to him and his issues. I take full responsibility sometimes for a month straight w/o help, w/o a break, w/o sleep so it\'s hard to pretend I care that his girlfriend (who he picked out) is driving him crazy and won\'t let him get the car. No not my problem...too busy with the kids to care. All you can do is stay positive and focused on the kids cuz in the end they depend on us and often times only us.

Add a comment

  
I agree to walrusmagazine.com’s comments policy.

Canada & its place in the world. Published by
the non-profit charitable Walrus Foundation
TwitterFacebookRSS
On newsstands now
New Issue on Sale
June 2012
Subscribe online for as little as $2.49 an issue. Visit The Walrus Store
to buy prints of our covers
The Walrus Foundation National Event Guide

The Walrus HOOPP Pension Debate
Be It Resolved That Canadians Are Incapable
of Saving for Their Retirement Needs Alone

12 pm, Wednesday, May 30 at
Hart House Debate Room, Toronto

The Walrus Glenbow Debate
Calgary’s Cowboy Culture:
Living Legacy or Just History?

6:30 pm, Thursday, June 7 at
Epcor Centre: Max Bell Theatre, Calgary

The Walrus Laughs
The Walrus SoapBox